Three Generations

Written by

in

On May 2, 1927, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that the state of Virginia could sterilize a young woman against her will. The vote was eight to one. The opinion was written by Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., one of the most admired judges in American history, and it closed with eight words that have never stopped echoing: “Three generations of imbeciles are enough.”

The young woman was Carrie Buck. She had been eighteen when her case was tried.

What the record shows

Carrie Buck was a foster child in Charlottesville. In the summer of 1923 she became pregnant. She said she had been raped by a nephew of the family that had taken her in. On January 23, 1924, at her foster parents’ petition, a court declared the seventeen-year-old feebleminded and committed her. Her daughter Vivian was born that March. In June she entered the Virginia State Colony for Epileptics and Feeble-Minded, where her mother was already held.

That is the “three generations”: a woman in an institution, her daughter, and a baby not yet a year old when the case began.

Virginia had passed its sterilization law on March 20, 1924. It was closely based on a model statute drafted by Harry Laughlin, superintendent of the Eugenics Record Office at Cold Spring Harbor — an office founded in 1910 by Charles Davenport on a grant from Mary Harriman, and funded from 1918 by the Carnegie Institution of Washington. That October of 1910, Davenport had written to Francis Galton to tell him the office existed: “the seed sown by you is still sprouting in distant countries.”

So the law Virginia applied to Carrie Buck was written by the movement that wanted the law, tested in a case the colony itself brought, and defended by an attorney who had drafted the statute. Laughlin’s testimony was submitted in writing, in his absence. He had never met her.

The evidence against the child

The case against Vivian rested largely on a visit. Arthur Estabrook, a field worker from the same Eugenics Record Office, examined the baby. A social worker said the child “had a look about it that is not quite normal.”

Vivian Buck was placed on her school’s honor roll in April 1931. She died the following year, at eight. Historians who have gone back through the records have found no evidence that she or her mother was ever impaired. A teacher wrote that Carrie was “very good” in deportment and lessons. She read for pleasure until her death in 1983.

She was sterilized on October 19, 1927, five months after the ruling.

What followed

About 8,300 Virginians were sterilized between 1927 and 1972. In the decade after Buck, almost 28,000 Americans were. The procedure fell most heavily on the poor, the institutionalized, and people with no one to speak for them.

The decision also traveled. At the later Nuremberg trials, counsel for the SS official Otto Hofmann cited Holmes’s opinion in Buck v. Bell as part of his defense.

And it is still there. Skinner v. Oklahoma (1942) struck down the sterilization of habitual criminals and unsettled the reasoning, but it did not overturn Buck v. Bell, and the Supreme Court never has.

The sentence underneath the sentence

The line that gets quoted is not the most revealing one. This is: “The principle that sustains compulsory vaccination is broad enough to cover cutting the Fallopian tubes.”

Holmes is reasoning by extension. If the state may compel one thing done to a body for the common good, the principle reaches further. The argument is not about medicine. It is about what a person is, and who decides. Once a human being is classified as a cost the public should not have to carry, everything after that is administration.

That premise is the one the Bible contradicts at the first chapter. “So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them” (Genesis 1:27). The image is not awarded for capacity. It is not forfeited by a diagnosis, a test score, or a court’s judgment about a family. It is what a person is.

Scripture then puts the weight exactly where the record shows it falls. “Give justice to the weak and the fatherless; maintain the right of the afflicted and the destitute” (Psalm 82:3). Carrie Buck was weak, fatherless, afflicted and destitute. She was also, by every account recovered since, perfectly ordinary.

Why this belongs in a series like this

This is history, not accusation. No one in it needs to be called a monster for the case to be instructive. Holmes believed he was being rational. The colony believed it was being responsible. The science of the day agreed with them, and the science of the day was wrong — not merely about Carrie Buck, but about the premise that human worth is a measurable quantity the competent may assess in the incompetent.

That premise did not die in 1927, and it is not hard to find now in the language of optimization, enhancement, and quality of life. The eight words are the warning. So is the honor roll.

“Open your mouth for the mute, for the rights of all who are destitute. Open your mouth, judge righteously, defend the rights of the poor and needy.” (Proverbs 31:8–9)

Primary texts: Genesis 1:27; Psalm 82:3; Proverbs 31:8-9. Buck v. Bell, 274 U.S. 200 (1927). Virginia Sterilization Act, March 20, 1924. Harry H. Laughlin, Eugenical Sterilization in the United States (1922). Charles Davenport to Francis Galton, 26 October 1910, reproduced in Karl Pearson, The Life, Letters and Labours of Francis Galton, vol. IIIB. Paul A. Lombardo, Three Generations, No Imbeciles: Eugenics, the Supreme Court, and Buck v. Bell (Johns Hopkins University Press, 2008). Stephen Jay Gould, “Carrie Buck’s Daughter,” Natural History (1984).

The full account of the Eugenics Record Office and what grew from it is in PHARMED, part of The Image Series.